2503 Highland Avenue , New Castle, PA

$324,900

Previous Next

4

Beds

3

Baths

0.54

Acres

About 2503 Highland Avenue

Timeless character, impressive craftsmanship, and a standout Upper North Hill location come together in this exceptional home. Prominently situated on the corner of Hazelcroft and Highland, this property has even been featured in the Lawrence County Tour of Homes—a testament to its distinctive charm and presence. Inside, beautiful hardwood floors, spacious rooms, and classic architectural details create a warm yet refined atmosphere throughout. The first floor also features a dedicated den/office space, perfect for working from home, a quiet reading room, or additional everyday living space. The home offers three traditional bedrooms, along with a beautifully remodeled finished attic featuring its own bathroom and storage area that can easily serve as a fourth bedroom, guest suite, home office, or additional living space. The second-floor main bathroom has also been thoughtfully remodeled. The outdoor space is just as impressive. A five-foot privacy fence surrounds the backyard and side yard, creating a private setting for the 27-foot round Ohana pool. A rare three-stall garage provides exceptional parking and storage, complemented by updated garage doors and a backyard shed for even more functionality. Additional improvements include a newer furnace and central air conditioning system, hot water tank, bathroom renovations, fencing, garage updates, and pool—blending the beauty and character of a classic North Hill home with the comfort of meaningful modern updates. From its stately corner setting and gorgeous hardwood floors to its flexible living spaces, private backyard, pool, and impressive three-stall garage, this Upper North Hill home offers a truly special combination of history, character, and modern-day living.

Features of 2503 Highland Avenue

MLS® # 1772829
Price $324,900
Bedrooms 4
Bathrooms 3.00
Full Baths 3
Acres 0.54
Year Built 1925
Type Residential
Sub-Type Single Family Residence
Style Two Story
Status Active

Community Information

Address 2503 Highland Avenue
Area New Castle/2nd
City New Castle
County Lawrence
State PA
Zip Code 16105

Amenities

Parking Attached, Garage
Is Waterfront No
Has Pool No

Interior

Appliances Some Electric Appliances, Dryer, Dishwasher, Refrigerator, Stove, Washer
Heating Forced Air, Gas
Cooling Central Air
Fireplace No
# of Stories 2
Stories Two

Exterior

Lot Description 0.54

School Information

District New Castle

Additional Information

Date Listed September 3rd, 2026
Days on Market 11

Listing Details

OfficeRE/MAX INFINITY
Contact Inforemaxinfinitybutler@gmail.com

Listing Map

Request a Showing

Provide a valid email address.
When would you like to view this property?